Bandita’s First Night Home

Our kitten hid under the bed for her entire first afternoon, and then cried in her cage until almost three in the morning. Nothing was wrong with her. She was two pounds, she had lost everything familiar in a single day, and she was frightened. This is what that night was like, and what we changed over the days that followed.

Some links below are affiliate or referral links. We earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only recommend what we actually use for Bandita, Whitey, and Shempy. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

What we walked in with

We brought Bandita home on February 13th, 2026, a Friday, about an hour after the rescue texted to say a kitten was available. I had bought the basics in one nervous trip that morning: a carrier, dry food, wet food, litter and a litter box, and a few toys. I did not know what I was doing. I had never had a cat.

We set her up in the bedroom, with the litter box in the bathroom. Roland did the honors, gently guiding her paw into the box so she would know where it was.

Then she went under the bed and stayed there.

The first night

From that afternoon until night, she did not come out. Not for food, not for us. Roland said we should let her come to us, so we sat in the room and waited, which turned out to be the best advice anyone gave us the whole week.

At bedtime we put her in a cage, to keep her safe overnight in a room we had not fully kitten-proofed. She panicked. She meowed without stopping, and nothing we did settled her, and I lay there at one in the morning wondering whether I had made a serious mistake.

What finally worked was a blanket over the cage. She stopped almost immediately. She slept around three.

I have thought about that a lot since. The cage was not the problem. The cage being open and exposed was the problem. She wanted a dark place with walls, and I had given her a safe place she could see out of in every direction, which to a two-pound animal is not safety at all.

The next few days

The next morning she came out of the cage. She explored a little, hid a lot, and went back under the bed when anything moved too fast. We kept her in the bedroom for the first couple of weeks rather than opening up the house, which in hindsight is the single thing I would tell myself to do again.

The day after that, she climbed onto the bed, walked across me, and bit my nose.

That was the beginning. From then on she went to her dad for long stretches of petting in the mornings, a routine the two of them still keep. At night she learned to crawl under my sheet, travel up to my face, and bite me lightly, or climb the pillows.

So I added a wind-down: play before bed to burn off the energy, then settle her for the night. She accepted the new arrangement, and promptly invented a new problem, crying early each morning until I opened the door. Every solution with a kitten seems to hand you the next puzzle. That one took patience and a consistent routine rather than opening the door every time she asked, because opening the door every time she asked would have taught her that crying opens doors.

The problem I did not expect

The litter smell.

The bedroom did not ventilate well, the door stayed closed, and by the end of that first week the room was unpleasant in a way I had not anticipated. I am a sustainability professional. I read labels for a living. It had not occurred to me to read one before buying cat litter, and standing in that stuffy room at the end of a long week was the moment it started to.

What we started with, and why we changed

We bought Purina Tidy Cats Lightweight on that first nervous trip, because it was on the shelf and it was easy to carry to the car. In a closed bedroom in February it was the wrong choice for us. The smell was the first thing I noticed and the dust was the second.

This is not us calling it a bad product. Plenty of people use it happily in a bigger, better-ventilated room. It was wrong for one small space, a fragrance-sensitive household, and eventually three cats.

It also did not resolve quickly. We tried several litters through the spring before we settled, months after the night this post is about.

What we use now: Purina Tidy Cats Free and Clean Unscented Clumping Multi Cat
Why it is here: two things changed from that first bag, and both were label decisions. The fragrance is gone, and it is the regular-weight clumping formula rather than the lightweight one, which is where the dust was in our house.
People / Planet / Value: People: high · Planet: low · Value: high
What we have seen: in daily use since spring 2026. Every scented litter we tried set off sneezing, mine more or less constantly and Whitey’s for long stretches after he came out of the box. Switching to unscented ended it. This one was low dust and controlled odor from the first bag, with no fragrance doing that work for it.
The transparent part: this is still a mainstream clay litter rather than a plant-based one. Clay is strip-mined and it is heavy to ship. We went with what controlled odor in a small desert house, and that is a trade-off rather than a clean win.
Where to get it: Tidy Cats Free and Clean Unscented Clumping on Amazon

That is where the standard behind this whole site came from. Not from a plan. From a stuffy bedroom and a bag of litter I had grabbed without looking.

One note on the toys

Of the things I bought in that first panicked trip, the toys are the ones I would spend the least on
again. We have since tried a laser and an automatic rolling ball, and both are fine. The laser turned
out to frustrate our three, because a cat hunts in a sequence that ends in a catch and a dot can never
be caught. If you use one, finish every session by landing the dot on something they can physically
get, so the hunt closes.

What our cats actually settled on was a sock stuffed with packaging paper, and cardboard boxes. Those
are the toys they come back to. Buy the carrier, the litter box and the food properly. The toys can
wait until you know the cat.

What I would do differently

Four things, and none of them are complicated.

I would have covered the cage on the first night instead of the second. I would have thought about ventilation before I thought about anything else. I would have read the litter label in the shop rather than in the bedroom a week later. And I would have worried a great deal less about the hiding, which lasted two days and felt like two weeks.

Questions people have asked us

Did she sleep in your bed that first night?
No. She was in a covered cage, and I think that was right for her, though I know people who do it differently. She sleeps wherever she likes now. She has strong opinions about it.

Was hiding all day normal?
It was for her, and the rescue had told us to expect it. She had lost her brother not long before we got her and she was very shy when we met her. Two days of hiding turned into a cat who walks across my face at six in the morning, so I would not read much into the first day.

When would you have called the vet?
If she had not eaten or had anything to drink for more than a day, or if she had seemed lethargic rather than frightened. We are not veterinarians. This is our experience, not veterinary advice, and anything that worries you is worth a phone call.

Where we are now

Bandita is a year old, she lives with two brothers she did not ask for, and she still bites my nose. The first night felt enormous while we were in it. It turned out to be two difficult days and one blanket.

More of what earned its place in our house, and what did not, is on our Practical Purrs Picks page.

What we would buy again

Everything we kept after the first months, with what worked and what did not: litter, toys, food and water.

Your turn: what was your first night like? Tell us in the comments.